Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

SOE WAS LEGAL, DENYING LAWYERS WAS NOT — PRIVY COUNCIL RULES

November 17, 2026

The Privy Council has upheld the constitutionality of Trinidad and Tobago’s 2011 State of Emergency (SOE), but ruled that police violated the constitutional rights of two detainees by denying them access to legal representation.

In a landmark judgment delivered today, November 17, the country’s highest appellate court rejected a challenge to the emergency declared under the Kamla Persad-Bissessar administration, finding that the extraordinary levels of violent crime justified the declaration and the emergency regulations.

However, the judges ruled that national security concerns did not justify denying detainees their constitutional right to consult an attorney.

The court restored $50,000 in compensation each to Sergeant Earl Elie and Dominic Pitilal, overturning a previous Court of Appeal decision that had removed those awards.

Both men had already been awarded $100,000 each for unlawful arrest and detention, bringing their individual compensation awards to $150,000 each.

The court rejected the argument that detainees must prove additional harm before receiving compensation for being denied legal advice.

It also rejected the suggestion that the seriousness of national security allegations could justify withholding access to lawyers.

The third appellant, Ashmeed Mohammed, was unsuccessful in his challenge.

The fundamental decision is clear: A State of Emergency can be constitutional, but its enforcement must still respect constitutional rights.

The judgment, Dominic Pitilal, Earl Elie and Ashmeed Mohammed v Attorney General, [2026] UKPC 41, also carries potential implications for more recent states of emergency in Trinidad and Tobago, although the court did not determine their legality.

Follow us on Instagram: @news.tringlobe
Follow WhatsApp channel: Tringlobe Media WhatsApp Channel
Join a WhatsApp group: Join Trinidad WhatsApp group

Follow our Whatsapp channel
Like and follow us on Facebook
News Desk
News Desk
News Desk is the editorial publishing account for Tringlobe Media News, covering breaking news, public affairs, entertainment, community developments and regional stories across Trinidad and Tobago, the Caribbean and internationally.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Popular Articles

Click to listen highlighted text!