The Dog Debate Malaysia Keeps Having, And The Licensing Fix Nobody Wants To Talk About

A woman in Johor was left in an induced coma after being attacked by a pack of five dogs near her grandmother’s home in Kampung Tambak, Sungai Kelambu, Peserai. The victim, identified as Nur Haira, was rushed to a hospital where surgery was performed and she remains in stable condition.

The incident has reignited debate in Malaysia over the ownership of pets and the country’s lack of a mandatory microchipping, licensing or registration system for dogs. Advocates argue that such measures would allow owners to be traced, fund shelters and support sterilisation programmes.

Celebrity preacher Haris Ismail, also known as PU Riz and husband of actress Neelofa, posted on the social media platform Threads expressing his view that urban residents should not keep dogs as pets. He cited religious guidance, stating that Islam discourages keeping dogs purely as indoor pets but permits them for guarding property, farms and livestock. Haris also expressed sympathy for those bitten by dogs and said he does not favour the presence of dogs, whether pets or strays, including in the homes of non‑Muslim neighbours.

Comments on the post were mixed. Some users agreed with Haris, while others criticised him for not addressing animal cruelty and irresponsible pet ownership. One user called for compulsory microchipping and registration of pets, suggesting that an annual licence fee could fund animal shelters, sterilisation programmes and other welfare initiatives.

Malaysia’s Animal Welfare Act 2015 allows fines of up to RM100,000 and up to three years in prison for cruelty or abandonment. Enforcement, however, is largely left to local councils, many of which continue to rely on catching and culling stray dogs. Critics say this approach has not reduced stray populations, as unsterilised dogs from nearby areas often move in to fill the gap.

Animal welfare groups advocate a Trap‑Neuter‑Return‑Manage (TNRM) strategy, arguing that sterilising stray dogs stabilises numbers and reduces aggressive behaviour. They contend that the root cause of Malaysia’s stray dog crisis is unsterilised pets roaming free, unregulated backyard breeding and owners abandoning animals without consequence. Without a mandatory microchipping or centralised registration system, abandoned pets cannot be traced back to their owners.

Nur Haira’s attack is described by advocates as a tragedy that highlights systemic shortcomings rather than a problem with dogs themselves.

For more information, readers can follow updates on TRP’s Facebook, X, Instagram or Threads.

Article and image source: therakyatpost.com