Shamfa questions Farley’s response to Government’s abstention on ICC resolution.

Shamfa Cudjoe-Lewis Challenges Farley Augustine Over Government's ICC Abstention and ANR Robinson's International Legacy

Political Leader of the People's National Movement (PNM) Tobago Council, Shamfa Cudjoe-Lewis, has renewed her criticism of the Government of Trinidad and Tobago over its decision to abstain from a United Nations resolution concerning the International Criminal Court (ICC), while challenging Tobago Chief Secretary Farley Augustine to take a stronger public stand in defence of the international legacy of former Prime Minister and President A.N.R. Robinson.

In an impassioned public address, Cudjoe-Lewis questioned the Government's decision and expressed disappointment with what she considers an inadequate response from Tobago's leadership on an issue deeply connected to the island's history.

More than two weeks after Trinidad and Tobago abstained from supporting the resolution, she argued that the country owes its citizens an explanation, particularly given Robinson's instrumental role in advancing the establishment of the ICC.

The November 2, 2026, resolution was adopted by the United Nations General Assembly, with 93 countries voting in favour, 13 against and 36 abstaining, including Trinidad and Tobago.

For Cudjoe-Lewis, however, the controversy extends beyond international diplomacy. She believes it raises fundamental questions about Tobago's political representation, identity and willingness to defend the achievements of its own people.

Why ANR Robinson's Legacy Matters

Cudjoe-Lewis explained that several young people had contacted her seeking to understand the significance of the International Criminal Court and why Robinson's involvement remains so important.

She used the opportunity to revisit the former leader's contribution to international justice.

In 1989, while serving as Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago, Robinson brought renewed attention to the proposal for a permanent international criminal court at the United Nations.

His initiative helped revive international discussions that eventually contributed to the adoption of the Rome Statute in 1998 and the establishment of the ICC in 2002.

The court was created to prosecute individuals accused of some of the world's gravest crimes, including genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression, where the court has jurisdiction.

Robinson's advocacy earned him international recognition as one of the institution's founding figures.

Cudjoe-Lewis described the achievement as one of Robinson's most significant international contributions and something Tobagonians should take pride in.

She questioned why Trinidad and Tobago, having historically supported the institution's work, would now abstain from a resolution concerning its activities.

Shamfa Questions Farley's Response

While criticising Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar's administration, Cudjoe-Lewis directed much of her commentary toward Chief Secretary Farley Augustine.

She questioned why Tobago's leadership had not taken a more forceful position following the Government's decision.

Cudjoe-Lewis acknowledged Assemblyman Ricky Joefield for publicly expressing disappointment with the abstention but took issue with his suggestion that the Central Government ultimately has the authority to make such decisions and that Tobago must follow.

She argued that constitutional responsibility for foreign affairs should not prevent Tobago's elected representatives from expressing their views on issues affecting the island's history, values and international standing.

The PNM Tobago leader questioned whether political relationships were influencing the willingness of Tobago's leadership to challenge decisions taken by the Central Government.

She accused Augustine and the Prime Minister of celebrating Robinson's legacy when politically convenient while failing, in her view, to defend the principles associated with his international work.

These allegations reflect Cudjoe-Lewis's political assessment of the situation rather than established findings about either leader's motives.

A Direct Challenge to Tobago's Leadership

Cudjoe-Lewis also raised broader concerns about Tobago's political voice and its relationship with the Central Government.

She questioned whether Tobagonians had become too willing to accept decisions made in Trinidad without demanding explanations or asserting their own positions.

The former government minister argued that Tobago's elected representatives have a responsibility to advocate for the island's interests, including its historical achievements and contributions to international affairs.

She urged Tobagonians to question their representatives and insist that the island's political leadership remain accountable to the people who elected them.

Her criticism also extended to what she characterised as the growing political relationship between Augustine's administration and the United National Congress.

Cudjoe-Lewis suggested that political cooperation should not prevent Tobago's leadership from disagreeing publicly with the Central Government when necessary.

She called directly on Augustine to demonstrate greater independence and explain his position on the ICC resolution.

Farley Augustine Explains THA's Position

Augustine has since publicly addressed questions surrounding the Tobago House of Assembly's response.

Speaking on November 16, the Chief Secretary explained that foreign policy falls under the constitutional and legal responsibility of the Central Government and that the THA does not possess the authority to determine Trinidad and Tobago's international positions.

However, Augustine also argued that Tobago should have a stronger legally established voice in such matters.

He linked the issue to Tobago's longstanding autonomy discussions, suggesting that the island needs more than informal opportunities to express its views.

The Chief Secretary further stated that he had recently discussed the importance of the ICC with international diplomatic representatives during United Nations anniversary activities in Tobago.

He affirmed his belief that an international justice system remains essential for protecting human rights and promoting peace around the world.

His comments establish that Augustine has addressed the ICC issue publicly, although Cudjoe-Lewis continues to question whether his response goes far enough in challenging the Government's abstention.

Robinson's Own Words Revisited

One of the most significant elements of Cudjoe-Lewis's presentation was the inclusion of archival footage featuring Robinson reflecting on his involvement in the establishment of the International Criminal Court.

In the recording, Robinson recalled his experiences during the attempted coup of July 1990, when armed insurgents stormed Trinidad and Tobago's Parliament and held members of the Government hostage.

Robinson, who was Prime Minister at the time, described being wounded during the attack and refusing demands that he instruct government security forces to surrender.

He recalled how the attackers attempted to force him to announce that the Government had fallen.

Instead, he instructed the security forces to continue their response.

The former leader also reflected on his international advocacy and the circumstances that led to his recognition as a founding figure of the ICC.

His remarks highlighted his belief that international justice should extend beyond national borders and serve the interests of humanity.

The archival footage added historical context to Cudjoe-Lewis's argument, illustrating the personal experiences and international contributions of a leader whose name remains closely associated with Tobago's political history.

What Trinidad and Tobago's Abstention Means

The United Nations resolution concerned the ICC's annual report and the importance of international cooperation with the institution.

The resolution also addressed challenges facing the court, including threats and interference affecting its independence.

Trinidad and Tobago's abstention did not constitute a vote against the resolution, nor did it signal the country's withdrawal from the ICC.

Nevertheless, the decision represented a change from Trinidad and Tobago's support for similar resolutions in recent years.

The Government's position has attracted criticism from several political figures, including those who believe the country should continue demonstrating international support for the institution Robinson helped establish.

Cudjoe-Lewis also questioned whether Trinidad and Tobago's foreign-policy decisions were becoming too closely aligned with the United States.

That suggestion remains her political interpretation of the Government's actions and does not, by itself, establish the reasons behind the abstention.

A Broader Question for Tobagonians

Beyond the immediate disagreement between political leaders, Cudjoe-Lewis's address raises questions about the preservation of Tobago's historical legacy and the role of the island's elected representatives in national discussions.

She argued that Robinson's contribution should not be reduced to ceremonial recognition or political speeches but should remain relevant when decisions are made concerning the institutions he helped advance.

Her message also placed responsibility on ordinary Tobagonians to remain informed about the island's history and the achievements of its leaders.

For younger generations unfamiliar with Robinson's international work, the controversy has created an opportunity to revisit an important chapter in Trinidad and Tobago's contribution to global justice.

The ICC remains an institution associated with efforts to hold individuals accountable for serious international crimes, particularly in circumstances where national judicial systems are unwilling or unable genuinely to pursue prosecutions.

For Cudjoe-Lewis, that mission represents the principles Robinson championed and the international contribution she believes Tobago's leadership should defend.

The debate now centres on two related questions: why Trinidad and Tobago chose to abstain from the United Nations resolution, and what responsibility Tobago's political leadership has to publicly defend Robinson's legacy when national foreign-policy decisions become controversial.

As the discussion continues, the legacy of A.N.R. Robinson has once again become central to a wider national conversation about international justice, political representation and Tobago's place in the world.

News Desk: News Desk is the editorial publishing account for Tringlobe Media News, covering breaking news, public affairs, entertainment, community developments and regional stories across Trinidad and Tobago, the Caribbean and internationally.