Jamaican dancehall superstar Beenie Man has sparked a debate over Caribbean cultural history after claiming that Jamaica started Carnival before Trinidad and Tobago.
Speaking during an interview with Shani Kulture, the Grammy-winning entertainer stood by his position when questioned about which country first established Carnival.
When the interviewer sought clarification on whether he was suggesting that Jamaica had Carnival before Trinidad, Beenie Man confirmed his position and pointed to legendary Jamaican musician and bandleader Byron Lee.
“Overall, trust me, due to Byron Lee,” Beenie Man stated.
He argued that Trinidad’s earlier Carnival traditions were different from the modern celebrations associated with large music trucks and organised road festivities.
According to Beenie Man, Trinidad Carnival was originally associated with Jonkonnu and other traditional masquerade practices rather than the modern entertainment format.
The dancehall veteran credited Byron Lee with helping establish the style of Carnival celebrations he was describing.
“Yeah, Byron Lee started them things there,” he insisted.
Beenie Man also suggested that Lee’s involvement in Carnival stretched back approximately 60 years, presenting the Jamaican musician as a major figure in the development of the celebration.
During the exchange, the interviewer acknowledged that he had not completed his own historical research into the subject.
However, Beenie Man encouraged him to investigate the history and maintained that his account was serious.
“I’m not telling a joke thing,” he declared.
The comments have attracted attention because Trinidad and Tobago is widely recognised for its longstanding Carnival traditions, which have influenced celebrations throughout the Caribbean and internationally.
But What Do the Historical Facts Show?
While Byron Lee played a major role in developing Jamaica’s modern Carnival celebrations, historical records establish that Trinidad Carnival existed long before his involvement.
According to Trinidad and Tobago’s National Library and Information System Authority (NALIS), Carnival developed following the arrival of French settlers during the late 18th century, particularly after the Cedula of Population in 1783.
The celebrations incorporated French pre-Lenten masquerade traditions and were subsequently transformed by African cultural practices, particularly following emancipation in the 1830s.
Canboulay, stick fighting, drumming, masquerade and other forms of cultural expression became important parts of Trinidad’s Carnival identity.
By the 19th century, Trinidad already had an established street Carnival tradition.
Historical records also document decorated trucks and lorries taking part in Trinidad Carnival during the early 20th century, decades before Byron Lee established Jamaica Carnival. However, the use of those vehicles does not by itself establish who pioneered today’s amplified music-truck format.
In Jamaica, Carnival celebrations were taking place at the University of the West Indies, Mona, by the 1954–1955 academic year, influenced partly by students from Trinidad and other Caribbean territories.
Byron Lee later helped popularise Carnival across Jamaica, officially introducing Jamaica Carnival to the streets of Kingston on April 22, 1990.
Research published by the University of the West Indies also confirms that Lee and his Dragonaires band had participated in Trinidad Carnival for years before establishing the Jamaican event.
Jonkonnu, meanwhile, has a separate history, particularly in Jamaica, where its roots stretch back to the early 1700s. Although it shares masquerade and African cultural influences with Carnival, the two traditions are not historically identical.
The historical distinction is therefore clear: Byron Lee helped establish and popularise modern Jamaica Carnival, but the evidence does not support the claim that Jamaica started Carnival before Trinidad and Tobago.
Beenie Man’s comments have nevertheless reopened discussion about the origins of Caribbean Carnival and the contributions of different islands to its modern development.
Article and image source: facebook.com