Both of 18-year-old Amiyr Ali’s lungs were absent when an independent pathologist attempted a second post-mortem, his family says. The authorities should now give them a written account of what was documented during the first examination and what accompanied his body when it was released to the funeral home.
Ali was one of six people who died after two boats collided off Chaguaramas on 8 November. His family sought a second opinion because the State’s post-mortem left his cause of death listed as “undetermined”. If either lung was kept for further testing, the family deserves to know why, where it is and whether their pathologist can examine it. Whether the lungs were retained remains unverified.
The case raises a wider issue. A family deciding whether to seek a second opinion needs to know what material is available for examination and whom to contact for access. That information should be given in writing when the body is released, while the family can still make informed decisions about the examination and funeral arrangements.
The authorities should explain what the records show in Ali’s case and publish the procedure every family can expect to follow. Grieving relatives should be able to get those answers without having to take their case public.